| | | Nichols wins toss and will receive; PSU will defend south end zone |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic30 | PSU ball on PSU30. |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 52 yards to the NIC18, Anthony Pillari return 17 yards to the NIC35 (Bobby Lombardo). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic35 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Anthony Pillari. |
| Nic | 2-10 | at Nic35 | Robert Morris rush for 6 yards to the NIC41 (Jim Sestito;Dan Kelly). |
| Nic | 3-4 | at Nic41 | S. Smith-Vaughn rush for 3 yards to the NIC44 (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 4-1 | at Nic44 | Anthony Pillari punt BLOCKED, recovered by PSU Brend. Fontaine at NIC42, Brend. Fontaine for 20 yards to the NIC22 (Anthony Pillari) (blocked by Matt Fiore). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic22 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 13:38, PSU ball on NIC22. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic22 | Chris Francher rush for 12 yards to the NIC10, 1ST DOWN PSU (Brian Lewis). |
| Psu | 1-G | at Nic10 | Ty Long rush for 5 yards to the NIC5 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 2-G | at Nic05 | J.J. Brooks rush for no gain to the NIC5 (Brian Lewis). |
| Psu | 3-G | at Nic05 | Ty Long rush for 5 yards to the NIC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:42. |
| | | Chris. Mulcahy kick attempt good. |
| | | Plymouth St. 7, Nichols 0 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 22 yards, TOP 02:00 |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 55 yards to the NIC15, Anthony Pillari return 17 yards to the NIC32 (Bobby Lombardo). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic32 | NICHOLS drive start at 11:38. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic32 | Robert Morris rush for 7 yards to the NIC39 (Harry Fallon). |
| Nic | 2-3 | at Nic39 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger. |
| Nic | 3-3 | at Nic39 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger. |
| Nic | 4-3 | at Nic39 | Anthony Pillari punt 23 yards to the PSU38, TEAM return 0 yards to the PSU38, fumble by TEAM recovered by NIC TEAM at PSU38. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu38 | NICHOLS drive start at 10:34. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu38 | Robert Morris rush for 2 yards to the PSU36 (Matt MacLean). |
| Nic | 2-8 | at Psu36 | Robert Morris rush for 1 yard to the PSU35 (Harry Fallon;Mike Bruning). |
| Nic | 3-7 | at Psu35 | S. Smith-Vaughn sacked for loss of 4 yards to the PSU39 (Matt Fiore;Matt MacLean). |
| Nic | 4-11 | at Psu39 | Timeout Nichols, clock 08:41. |
| Nic | 4-11 | at Psu39 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Mike Seiger for 15 yards to the PSU24, 1ST DOWN NIC (Harry Fallon). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu24 | Robert Morris rush for no gain to the PSU24 (Dan Kelly). |
| Nic | 2-10 | at Psu24 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 6 yards to the PSU18 (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 3-4 | at Psu18 | PENALTY PSU offside 5 yards to the PSU13, 1ST DOWN NIC. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu13 | PENALTY NIC false start 5 yards to the PSU18. |
| Nic | 1-15 | at Psu18 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger (Chris. Mulcahy). |
| Nic | 2-15 | at Psu18 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 11 yards to the PSU7 (Dan Kelly). |
| Nic | 3-4 | at Psu07 | PENALTY NIC false start 5 yards to the PSU12. |
| Nic | 3-9 | at Psu12 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Mike Seiger for 10 yards to the PSU2, 1ST DOWN NIC (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 1-G | at Psu02 | Robert Morris rush for 1 yard to the PSU1 (Br. Castellucci;Mike Carone). |
| Nic | 2-G | at Psu01 | S. Smith-Vaughn rush for 1 yard to the PSU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:23, Dave Wyrick kick attempt failed. |
| | | Plymouth St. 7, Nichols 6 |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 38 yards, TOP 06:18 |
| | | Dave Wyrick kickoff 50 yards to the PSU20, Chris. Mulcahy return 16 yards to the PSU36 (C. Kerrigan;Peter Curto). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu36 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 04:16. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu36 | Chris Francher rush for 3 yards to the PSU39 (Zach Mihaly). |
| Psu | 2-7 | at Psu39 | Ty Long rush for 4 yards to the PSU43 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 3-3 | at Psu43 | Ty Long rush for 2 yards to the PSU45 (Evan Greathead). |
| Psu | 4-1 | at Psu45 | Nick Provost punt 39 yards to the NIC16, Jonathon Turner return 6 yards to the NIC22 (Matt MacLean). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:18 |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic22 | NICHOLS drive start at 01:58. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic22 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass intercepted by Dan Kelly at the NIC31, Dan Kelly return 31 yards to the NIC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:48, PENALTY NIC holding declined, Chris. Mulcahy kick attempt good. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:10 |
| | | Plymouth St. 14, Nichols 6 |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 50 yards to the NIC20, Lawrence Scott return 17 yards to the NIC37 (Chad Croteau;Joel Mignault). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic37 | NICHOLS drive start at 01:41. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic37 | Robert Morris rush for 4 yards to the NIC41 (Zach Parsons). |
| Nic | 2-6 | at Nic41 | Robert Morris rush for 1 yard to the NIC42 (Jim Sestito). |
| Nic | 3-5 | at Nic42 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 4 yards to the NIC46 (Chris. Mulcahy), PENALTY NIC unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the NIC31. |
| Nic | 3-16 | at Nic31 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 15 yards to the NIC46 (Chris. Mulcahy), PENALTY NIC unsportsmanlike conduct 15 yards to the NIC31. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| | | Plymouth St. 14, Nichols 6 |
| Nic | 4-16 | at Nic31 | 4th and 16, start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Nic | 4-16 | at Nic31 | Anthony Pillari punt 25 yards to the PSU44, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu44 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 14:52. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu44 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to John Creamer for 13 yards to the NIC43, 1ST DOWN PSU (Jeramie White). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic43 | J.J. Brooks rush for 16 yards to the NIC27, 1ST DOWN PSU (Brandon Wallace). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic27 | Ty Long rush for 3 yards to the NIC24 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 2-7 | at Nic24 | J.J. Brooks sacked for loss of 2 yards to the NIC26 (Patrick Gregory). |
| Psu | 3-9 | at Nic26 | Ty Long rush for 5 yards to the NIC21 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 4-4 | at Nic21 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to John Creamer for 21 yards to the NIC0, 1ST DOWN PSU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:39, Chris. Mulcahy kick attempt good. |
| | | Plymouth St. 21, Nichols 6 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 56 yards, TOP 03:23 |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 47 yards to the NIC23, Lawrence Scott return 23 yards to the NIC46 (Harry Fallon;Joel Mignault). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic46 | NICHOLS drive start at 11:29. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic46 | PENALTY NIC false start 5 yards to the NIC41. |
| Nic | 1-15 | at Nic41 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Mike Seiger for 16 yards to the PSU43, 1ST DOWN NIC (Chris. Mulcahy). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu43 | Robert Morris rush for 2 yards to the PSU41 (Jim Sestito). |
| Nic | 2-8 | at Psu41 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 12 yards to the PSU29, 1ST DOWN NIC (Dan Kelly). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu29 | Robert Morris rush for no gain to the PSU29 (Mike Carone;Br. Castellucci). |
| Nic | 2-10 | at Psu29 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger. |
| Nic | 3-10 | at Psu29 | S. Smith-Vaughn sacked for loss of 6 yards to the PSU35 (Alex Battaglino). |
| Nic | 4-16 | at Psu35 | Anthony Pillari punt 21 yards to the PSU14, fair catch by Ty Long. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 19 yards, TOP 02:46 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu14 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 08:43. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu14 | J.J. Brooks rush for 1 yard to the PSU15 (Roy Burke). |
| Psu | 2-9 | at Psu15 | J.J. Brooks rush for 1 yard to the PSU16 (Brian Lewis;Anthony Freni). |
| Psu | 3-8 | at Psu16 | J.J. Brooks sacked for loss of 6 yards to the PSU10 (Patrick Gregory). |
| Psu | 4-14 | at Psu10 | Nick Provost punt 47 yards to the NIC43, Jonathon Turner return 4 yards to the NIC47 (Mike Bruning). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 4 yards, TOP 02:11 |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic47 | NICHOLS drive start at 06:32. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic47 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger. |
| Nic | 2-10 | at Nic47 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger. |
| Nic | 3-10 | at Nic47 | S. Smith-Vaughn sacked for no gain to the NIC47 (Matt Fiore;Jim Sestito), PENALTY PSU personal foul 15 yards to the PSU38, 1ST DOWN NIC, NO PLAY. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu38 | Robert Morris rush for no gain to the PSU38, fumble forced by Harry Fallon, fumble by Robert Morris recovered by NIC Charles Baker at PSU45. |
| Nic | 2-17 | at Psu45 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 40 yards to the PSU5, 1ST DOWN NIC. |
| Nic | 1-G | at Psu05 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to R.J. Gagne for loss of 1 yard to the PSU6 (Zach Parsons). |
| Nic | 2-G | at Psu06 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 6 yards to the PSU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:24, S. Smith-Vaughn pass attempt failed. |
| | | Plymouth St. 21, Nichols 12 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 53 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| | | Dave Wyrick kickoff 49 yards to the PSU21, Chris. Mulcahy return 13 yards to the PSU34 (Josh Arce). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu34 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 04:16. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu34 | J.J. Brooks rush for 13 yards to the PSU47, 1ST DOWN PSU (Roy Burke). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu47 | J.J. Brooks rush for 7 yards to the NIC46 (Roy Burke;Elwin McCarthy), PENALTY PSU holding 10 yards to the PSU37, NO PLAY. |
| Psu | 1-20 | at Psu37 | Ty Long rush for 3 yards to the PSU40 (J. Merjuste). |
| Psu | 2-17 | at Psu40 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to Aaron Getz for 14 yards to the NIC46 (Evan Greathead). |
| Psu | 3-3 | at Nic46 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to Alex Smith for 34 yards to the NIC12, 1ST DOWN PSU (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic12 | Chris Francher rush for 7 yards to the NIC5 (Evan Greathead). |
| Psu | 2-3 | at Nic05 | Ty Long rush for 3 yards to the NIC2, 1ST DOWN PSU (Elwin McCarthy;Brandon Wallace). |
| Psu | 1-G | at Nic02 | Chris Francher rush for 2 yards to the NIC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:46, Chris. Mulcahy kick attempt failed. |
| | | Plymouth St. 27, Nichols 12 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 66 yards, TOP 03:38 |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 49 yards to the NIC21, Lawrence Scott return 20 yards to the NIC41 (Mike Ladd). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic41 | NICHOLS drive start at 00:38. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic41 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Jonathon Turner for 11 yards to the PSU48, 1ST DOWN NIC (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu48 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 12 yards to the PSU36, 1ST DOWN NIC (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu36 | Timeout Nichols, clock 00:18. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu36 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Brandon Haddad (Zach Parsons). |
| Nic | 2-10 | at Psu36 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Anthony Pillari. |
| Nic | 3-10 | at Psu36 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete. |
| Nic | 4-10 | at Psu36 | Timeout Nichols, clock 00:02. |
| Nic | 4-10 | at Psu36 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete (Jim Sestito). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 23 yards, TOP 00:38 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu36 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 00:00. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu36 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Plymouth St. 27, Nichols 12 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu36 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu36 | NIC ball on NIC30. |
| | | Dave Wyrick kickoff 50 yards to the PSU20, Chris. Mulcahy return 10 yards to the PSU30 (Lawrence Scott). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu30 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 14:54. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu30 | Chris Francher rush for 2 yards to the PSU32 (Zach Mihaly). |
| Psu | 2-8 | at Psu32 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to John Creamer for 41 yards to the NIC27, 1ST DOWN PSU. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic27 | Ty Long rush for 9 yards to the NIC18 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 2-1 | at Nic18 | Chris Francher rush for no gain to the NIC18 (Patrick Gregory). |
| Psu | 3-1 | at Nic18 | J.J. Brooks rush for 2 yards to the NIC16, 1ST DOWN PSU (Evan Greathead;Brian Lewis). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic16 | J.J. Brooks rush for 2 yards to the NIC14 (J. Merjuste). |
| Psu | 2-8 | at Nic14 | J.J. Brooks rush for 10 yards to the NIC4, 1ST DOWN PSU (Brandon Wallace). |
| Psu | 1-G | at Nic04 | Chris Francher rush for 1 yard to the NIC3 (Mike Rubalcaba;Evan Greathead). |
| Psu | 2-G | at Nic03 | Zac Duval rush for 3 yards to the NIC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:13, Chris. Mulcahy kick attempt good. |
| | | Plymouth St. 34, Nichols 12 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 70 yards, TOP 04:50 |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 51 yards to the NIC19, Lawrence Scott return 11 yards to the NIC30 (Kevin Whalen;Matt MacLean). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic30 | NICHOLS drive start at 10:04. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic30 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Mike Seiger for 12 yards to the NIC42, 1ST DOWN NIC (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic42 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete (Mike Bruning). |
| Nic | 2-10 | at Nic42 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Jonathon Turner. |
| Nic | 3-10 | at Nic42 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Mike Seiger for 7 yards to the NIC49 (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 4-3 | at Nic49 | Anthony Pillari punt 31 yards to the PSU20, Ty Long return 0 yards to the PSU20 (Matt O'Shea). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 19 yards, TOP 01:20 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu20 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 08:44. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu20 | Chris Francher rush for 1 yard to the PSU21 (Justin Ward). |
| Psu | 2-9 | at Psu21 | Ty Long rush for 8 yards to the PSU29 (Brandon Wallace). |
| Psu | 3-1 | at Psu29 | J.J. Brooks rush for 2 yards to the PSU31, 1ST DOWN PSU (J. Merjuste). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu31 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to Alex Smith for 69 yards to the NIC0, 1ST DOWN PSU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:37, Chris. Mulcahy kick attempt good. |
| | | Plymouth St. 41, Nichols 12 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 80 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 57 yards to the NIC13, Anthony Pillari return 13 yards to the NIC26 (Derek Lussier). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic26 | NICHOLS drive start at 06:28. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic26 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Robert Morris for loss of 3 yards to the NIC23. |
| Nic | 2-13 | at Nic23 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger (Chris. Mulcahy). |
| Nic | 3-13 | at Nic23 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 16 yards to the NIC39, 1ST DOWN NIC (Kevin Whalen). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic39 | Robert Morris rush for loss of 2 yards to the NIC37 (Alex Battaglino;Matt Fiore). |
| Nic | 2-12 | at Nic37 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Mike Seiger. |
| Nic | 3-12 | at Nic37 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Brandon Haddad (Chris. Mulcahy). |
| Nic | 4-12 | at Nic37 | Anthony Pillari punt 29 yards to the PSU34, downed, PENALTY PSU roughing the kicker 15 yards to the PSU48, 1ST DOWN NIC, NO PLAY. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu48 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Mike Seiger for 48 yards to the PSU0, 1ST DOWN NIC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 04:00, Evan Greathead rush attempt failed (fumbled), returned by Kevin Whalen - no score. |
| | | Plymouth St. 41, Nichols 18 |
| Nic | 1-G | at Nic30 | PENALTY PSU personal foul 15 yards to the NIC45, Dave Wyrick kickoff 55 yards to the PSU0, Louis Montegari return 10 yards to the PSU10 (Josh Arce). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 74 yards, TOP 02:34 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu10 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 03:54. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu10 | James Dionne rush for no gain to the PSU10 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 2-10 | at Psu10 | J.J. Brooks rush for 3 yards to the PSU13 (Evan Greathead). |
| Psu | 3-7 | at Psu13 | Chris Francher rush for 2 yards to the PSU15 (Justin Ward). |
| Psu | 4-5 | at Psu15 | Nick Provost punt 37 yards to the NIC48, downed, PENALTY NIC roughing the kicker 15 yards to the PSU30, 1ST DOWN PSU, NO PLAY. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu30 | Chris Francher rush for 2 yards to the PSU32 (Patrick Gregory). |
| Psu | 2-8 | at Psu32 | Ty Long rush for 5 yards to the PSU37 (Mike Rubalcaba;Lawrence Scott). |
| Psu | 3-3 | at Psu37 | J.J. Brooks rush for 8 yards to the PSU45, PENALTY PSU false start 5 yards to the PSU32, NO PLAY. |
| Psu | 3-8 | at Psu32 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to Joel Mignault for 12 yards to the PSU44, 1ST DOWN PSU. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 34 yards, TOP 08:45 |
| | | Plymouth St. 41, Nichols 18 |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu44 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu44 | J.J. Brooks rush for 7 yards to the NIC49 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 2-3 | at Nic49 | J.J. Brooks pass complete to Justin Kane for 12 yards to the NIC37, 1ST DOWN PSU. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic37 | Chris Francher rush for 3 yards to the NIC34 (Justin Ward;J. Merjuste). |
| Psu | 2-7 | at Nic34 | Ty Long rush for 4 yards to the NIC30 (Justin Ward;Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 3-3 | at Nic30 | Ty Long rush for 5 yards to the NIC25, PENALTY PSU holding 10 yards to the NIC35. |
| Psu | 3-8 | at Nic35 | 1st and 8, J.J. Brooks pass complete to Justin Kane for 9 yards to the NIC26, 1ST DOWN PSU (Roy Burke). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic26 | PENALTY PSU false start 5 yards to the NIC31. |
| Psu | 1-15 | at Nic31 | Ty Long rush for 6 yards to the NIC25 (Patrick Gregory). |
| Psu | 2-9 | at Nic25 | James Dionne rush for 25 yards to the NIC0, 1ST DOWN PSU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:26, Chris. Mulcahy kick attempt good. |
| | | Plymouth St. 48, Nichols 18 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 90 yards, TOP 08:45 |
| | | Plymouth St. 48, Nichols 24 |
| | | Sean Crowley kickoff 52 yards to the NIC18, Lawrence Scott return 82 yards to the PSU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:09, Dave Wyrick kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Dan Snyder). |
| | | Dave Wyrick kickoff 52 yards to the PSU18, Chris. Mulcahy return 23 yards to the PSU41 (C. Kerrigan). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu41 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 10:00. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Psu41 | Michael Malia rush for 12 yards to the NIC47, 1ST DOWN PSU (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic47 | Michael Malia rush for 3 yards to the NIC44 (Elwin McCarthy). |
| Psu | 2-7 | at Nic44 | James Dionne rush for 8 yards to the NIC36, 1ST DOWN PSU (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic36 | Michael Malia rush for 17 yards to the NIC19, 1ST DOWN PSU (Lawrence Scott). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic19 | Michael Malia rush for 1 yard to the NIC18 (Brian Lewis). |
| Psu | 2-9 | at Nic18 | Michael Malia rush for 6 yards to the NIC12 (Justin Ward). |
| Psu | 3-3 | at Nic12 | Michael Malia rush for 2 yards to the NIC10, PENALTY PSU holding 10 yards to the NIC20. |
| Psu | 3-11 | at Nic20 | 3rd and 11, James Dionne rush for 6 yards to the NIC14 (Lawrence Scott). |
| Psu | 4-5 | at Nic14 | James Dionne rush for 2 yards to the NIC12 (Zach Mihaly). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 47 yards, TOP 04:47 |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic12 | NICHOLS drive start at 05:13. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic12 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 50 yards to the PSU38, 1ST DOWN NIC (Derek Lussier;Joe Perry), PENALTY PSU offside declined. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu38 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 21 yards to the PSU17, 1ST DOWN NIC (Joe Perry). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu17 | Robert Morris rush for 4 yards to the PSU13 (Derek Lussier). |
| Nic | 2-6 | at Psu13 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete to Jonathon Turner (Bobby Lombardo), PENALTY PSU offside 5 yards to the PSU8, NO PLAY. |
| Nic | 2-1 | at Psu08 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 8 yards to the PSU0, 1ST DOWN NIC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:38, S. Smith-Vaughn pass attempt failed. |
| | | Plymouth St. 48, Nichols 30 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 88 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| | | Bill Crory kickoff 8 yards to the NIC38, on-side kick, recovered by PSU on NIC38. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic38 | PLYMOUTH ST. drive start at 03:36. |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic38 | Michael Malia rush for 3 yards to the NIC35 (J. Merjuste). |
| Psu | 2-7 | at Nic35 | Timeout Nichols, clock 03:26. |
| Psu | 2-7 | at Nic35 | James Dionne rush for 4 yards to the NIC31 (Roy Burke). |
| Psu | 3-3 | at Nic31 | Timeout Nichols, clock 03:20. |
| Psu | 3-3 | at Nic31 | Michael Malia rush for 4 yards to the NIC27, 1ST DOWN PSU (Brian Lewis). |
| Psu | 1-10 | at Nic27 | Alex Sobolov rush for 1 yard to the NIC26 (Roy Burke). |
| Psu | 2-9 | at Nic26 | Timeout Nichols, clock 02:40. |
| Psu | 2-9 | at Nic26 | Jon Brennan rush for 2 yards to the NIC24 (Brandon Wallace). |
| Psu | 3-7 | at Nic24 | Alex Sobolov rush for 1 yard to the NIC23 (Roy Burke). |
| Psu | 4-6 | at Nic23 | James Dionne rush for 2 yards to the NIC21 (Mike Rubalcaba). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 17 yards, TOP 02:34 |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic21 | NICHOLS drive start at 01:02. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic21 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete. |
| Nic | 2-10 | at Nic21 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Robert Morris for 14 yards to the NIC35, 1ST DOWN NIC (Derek Lussier), PENALTY PSU offside declined. |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Nic35 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Anthony Pillari for 9 yards to the NIC44 (Derek Lussier). |
| Nic | 2-1 | at Nic44 | PENALTY NIC false start 5 yards to the NIC39. |
| Nic | 2-6 | at Nic39 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass incomplete. |
| Nic | 3-6 | at Nic39 | S. Smith-Vaughn pass complete to Brandon Haddad for 23 yards to the PSU38, 1ST DOWN NIC (Matt Bailey). |
| Nic | 1-10 | at Psu38 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 41 yards, TOP 01:02 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Plymouth St. 48, Nichols 30 |